Books

AD| Review of Pagans by James Alistair Henry

March 7, 2025
A red background with white text that says It’s London, but not as you know it. The Norman Conquest, Christianity, and the Industrial Revolution never happened. The ancient tribes of Britain remain undefeated. And as a Unification Summit is about to begin, a string of murders starts. There is a copy of the book Pagans next to it that has a black background with a cream coloured sky scape with a drop of red blood falling on two silhouettes.

Disclosure: I was given a free copy of this book by the publisher in return for an honest review.

When I received an email from Moonflower Books about Pagans, I was immediately intrigued. The premise is this – in an alternative 21st Century London, where the Norman Conquest, Christianity, and the Industrial Revolution never happened, and the ancient tribes of Britain remained undefeated, what would a murder mystery look like? As someone who is fascinated by religion and politics, I was excited to see how this would play out. And I wasn’t disappointed.

Getting to grips with a new world

I’ll admit that when I first started reading Pagans it was a bit of a slog. I recently saw an amusing reel on instagram called “how to read fantasy” which summed up my experience perfectly. The reel talked about how reading fantasy takes you on a rambling journey of having no clue what is happening, then thinking you’ve got to grips with it, only to realise you still don’t really understand. And that’s exactly what the first third of this book was like for me.

The author has created an amazing world with incredibly in depth worldbuilding, but it really does take some time to wrap your head around this alternate world. I found myself regularly flipping back to the maps and cast of characters at the front of the book, and the glossary at the back for quite some time, and was very grateful for them. Because this world is very different, both within Britain itself and the world at large.

And yet, for all its differences, some things never change. Racism is still rife within this society, it simply has different targets. Politics is still as messay as always. And religion is still as divisive. And that is, in my opinion, the cleverest part of this story. In a world so different from our own, humans continue to be the same old humans – complex, conflicted, and in some cases, corrupt.

So what is Pagans about?

Pagans takes place as a Unification Summit is about to take place. We are told that this is something that happens every so many years, but this year there seems to be more hope of a step towards unifying Britain. But just as it is about to start, one of the delegates is found murdered – nailed to a tree in what readers will recognise as a crucifiction position. As the victim was a Tribal, one of their own people – DI Drustan – is sent to help the Saxon police in the investigation.

The story mostly revolves around Drustan’s POV and that of his new colleague – Detective Captain Aedith Mercia – as they follow an increasingly convoluted trail to find the killer. As more deaths occur, and the connections between the victims lead them down the routes of politics, religion, and revenge, we get a deeper understanding of the world in which they live and both the similarities and differences between them.

A book that feels like a TV series

One of the things that struck me whilst I was reading Pagans is that it felt like it would work so well as a TV series. It’s more than just a murder mystery – there is so much thrown in here, exploring the personal relationships of both Drustan and Aedith, as well as the history of the killer and how it all plays into what is happening. And even by the end of it, when everything has been tied up, you’re left with the feeling that there is so much more that could have been explored.

This shouldn’t be surprising, given that the author – James Alistair Henry – is a BAFTA- Award winning writing behind Green Wing, Smack The Pony, Bob The Builder, and Hey Duggie. It’s easy to see how this background plays into the way Pagans was developed and written. Having finished it, I can’t help but wonder whether there will be further books to come within this world. There’s certainly plenty of scope for it.

Get your copy of Pagans

All in all I would highly recommend this book to anyone who loves a good murder mystery, or who is interested in history, religion, or politics and wants to spend some time in an alternate Britain. You can buy a copy from Bookshop.org.


If you have enjoyed this post and found it useful, here are some ways you can support A Spiral Dance.

  1. Buy Me A Coffee – this is an easy way to support me financially, to help keep the blog going and cover my bills.
  2. Follow me on social media – I’m on Facebook, Threads, Bluesky, and Instagram.
  3. Share this post with others, either on social media or by using the image below to pin on Pinterest.
  4. Read and share some of my other posts. I have several posts about books you might like.
  5. If you’re a book lover, find my other reviews on Goodreads and The Storygraph
A red background with white text that says It’s London, but not as you know it. The Norman Conquest, Christianity, and the Industrial Revolution never happened. The ancient tribes of Britain remain undefeated. And as a Unification Summit is about to begin, a string of murders starts. There is a copy of the book Pagans next to it that has a black background with a cream coloured sky scape with a drop of red blood falling on two silhouettes.

    Leave a Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.